P.A.Y.
Skip to content
P.A.Y.Payroll All Year

Qualified, nonqualified, pension and equity

Types of employer retirement plans, and how vesting works

Qualified plans get special tax treatment in exchange for meeting IRS rules. Nonqualified plans and equity awards follow different tax rules and are not retirement plans in the same sense. Here is how they compare, and when employer money becomes yours.

Written by Robert Hartigos, 20+ years in payroll, HRIS and benefits · Last reviewed November 15, 2026

Compare plan typesSee how vesting works

Qualified vs nonqualified plans

Qualified plans, such as a 401(k), meet IRS rules on coverage, testing and vesting. Employer contributions to a qualified plan are not taxed when made. Nonqualified plans do not get that treatment. Employer payments into one are generally taxed as wages when made. The exception is when your interest is nontransferable or at substantial risk of forfeiture (IRS Publication 525).

Nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plans fall under Code section 409A. Deferred amounts that fail its rules become currently taxable and face additional taxes. Employers withhold income tax but not the extra 409A taxes. NQDC is subject to social security, Medicare and FUTA at the later of two dates. One is when the services are performed. The other is when it is no longer at substantial risk of forfeiture (IRS Publication 15-A).

Have tax or legal counsel review any NQDC plan for 409A compliance before the first deferral election.

Defined contribution vs defined benefit

A defined benefit pension plan promises a set monthly benefit at retirement. A defined contribution plan does not promise a specific amount. A cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan that states the promised benefit as an account balance. The employer bears the investment risk and reward. Benefits in most defined benefit plans are protected, within limits, by federal insurance through the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) (DOL).

The 2026 annual benefit limit for a defined benefit plan is $290,000 (IRS Notice 2025-67).

Comparison table: employer retirement plans

For 2027, the employee deferral limit for 401(k) and 403(b) plans rises to $25,500. Governmental 457(b) has a separate $25,500 limit. The defined contribution annual additions limit rises to $75,000 and the defined benefit annual limit to $300,000. The comparison table below shows 2026 amounts. See IRS Notice 2026-66 for the published 2027 amounts by plan type.

Employer retirement plan types compared (2026 limits)
PlanWhat it isWho puts money inKey 2026 limit
401(k)A defined contribution plan with a cash or deferred arrangement. Employees choose to defer part of their pay (DOL)Employee, and employer if the plan provides$24,500 deferrals; $72,000 total
Roth 401(k)A designated Roth account for after-tax deferrals. Qualified payouts are tax-free after 5 years and age 59 and a half, disability or death. No income limit to use it (IRS)EmployeeShares the $24,500 limit with pre-tax deferrals
403(b)Only public schools and 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organizations can offer one. It may also offer Roth accounts (IRS)Employee, and employer if the plan provides$24,500, added together with 401(k) deferrals
Governmental 457(b)Offered by a state or local government. Allows age 50 catch-ups and works much like a 401(k) (IRS)Employee, and employer if the plan providesIts own separate $24,500 limit; special catch-up in the 3 years before normal retirement age
Non-governmental 457(b)A tax-exempt employer's plan, limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees. Assets stay the employer's property and can be reached by its creditors (IRS)EmployeeNo age 50 catch-up
SIMPLE IRAFor small businesses, generally 100 or fewer employees. The employer must match up to 3% of pay or give a 2% nonelective contribution (IRS)Employee and employer$17,000 deferrals; always 100% vested
SEPThe employer contributes to traditional IRAs for employees. Generally no Form 5500 (IRS)Employer onlyLesser of 25% of pay or $72,000 (IRS Publication 560); always 100% vested
Profit-sharing planTakes discretionary employer contributions. The employer decides each year how much, and the business does not need profits to contribute (IRS)Employer$72,000 total with any deferrals
Defined benefit pensionPromises a set monthly benefit at retirement. Most are insured, within limits, by the PBGCEmployer$290,000 annual benefit
Cash balance planA defined benefit plan that states the benefit as an account balance. The employer bears the investment riskEmployerDefined benefit limits apply
NQDC (409A)A nonqualified plan. Failing 409A makes deferrals currently taxable with additional taxesEmployee deferrals, sometimes employer creditsNot subject to the qualified plan limits above
ESOPA qualified defined contribution plan designed to invest mainly in the employer's own stock (IRS)EmployerQualified plan limits apply
Equity plans (ESPP, options, RSUs)Equity pay, not retirement plans. See how equity differsEmployee purchases or employer awardsNot retirement plan limits

The $24,500 deferral limit is per person across 401(k), 403(b), SIMPLE and SARSEP plans. A 457(b) limit is separate, so a person in both a 403(b) and a 457(b) can defer the full amount in each (IRS). Total additions of $72,000 come from IRS Notice 2025-67. If you offer both a 403(b) and a 457(b), tell employees they can defer the full limit in each plan.

How equity plans differ from retirement plans

Stock options are equity pay, not retirement plans. Options under an employee stock purchase plan (ESPP) or an incentive stock option (ISO) plan are statutory options. All others are nonstatutory, and their value at exercise is generally income (IRS Topic 427).

Not fully confirmed. Restricted stock units (RSUs) are generally taxed as wages when the shares are delivered at vesting. The IRS restricted property text could not be read for this review. Confirm the details with your tax advisor or the IRS before you rely on them.

Treat ESPP, options and RSUs as part of pay, not a substitute for retirement savings. Try not to hold too much of your savings in one company's stock.

New in 2027: the Saver's Match

Starting in 2027, the federal Saver's Match will match up to 50% of retirement savings, up to $1,000 per person each year. It is for eligible lower and moderate income savers. The match goes into a retirement plan or IRA. Check the income limits on the IRS Saver's Match page.

How vesting works

Your own deferrals are always 100% vested (IRS). Employer contributions can follow a vesting schedule, but the law sets the slowest schedules allowed. In a defined contribution plan, one choice is a 3-year cliff: 0% until 3 years of service, then 100%. The other is a 6-year graded schedule: 20% after 2 years, 40% after 3, 60% after 4, 80% after 5 and 100% after 6 (IRS Issue Snapshot). A plan can vest faster, including immediately.

Vested share of employer contributions by years of service, at the slowest schedules allowed. 3-year cliff 6-year graded
Years3-year cliff6-year graded
10%0%
20%20%
3100%40%
4100%60%
5100%80%
6100%100%

Fictional example: Sam leaves after 4 years with $6,000 of employer match. Under the 6-year graded schedule, Sam keeps 60%, or $3,600. Under the 3-year cliff, Sam keeps all $6,000. Sam's own deferrals are 100% Sam's either way.

What payroll and HR should do

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a 401(k) and a 403(b)?

Both take employee deferrals under the same $24,500 limit in 2026. Only public schools and 501(c)(3) organizations can offer a 403(b). See the comparison table.

Is a pension the same as a 401(k)?

No. A pension promises a set monthly benefit, and the employer carries the investment risk. A 401(k) promises no set amount. See defined contribution vs defined benefit.

Are RSUs or stock options a retirement plan?

No. They are equity pay with their own tax rules. Treat them as part of pay, not a substitute for retirement savings. See how equity differs.

When does my employer match become mine?

It depends on your plan's vesting schedule. The slowest allowed are a 3-year cliff or a 6-year graded schedule. Your own deferrals are always yours. See how vesting works.

Official sources

IRS Notice 2026-66 reviewed November 15, 2026.

General information, not legal, tax or benefits advice. Your plan document decides your vesting schedule and plan features. Talk with a tax advisor about equity and nonqualified plans.