P.A.Y.
Skip to content
P.A.Y.Payroll All Year

For benefits, HRIS and payroll teams

Open enrollment to payroll: the 2027 runbook

Open enrollment ends with elections. Payroll starts with deductions. This runbook covers everything in between for the first 2027 payroll: timing, the data handoff, the math, testing, reconciliation and the errors to catch.

Written by Robert Hartigos, 20+ years in payroll, HRIS and benefits · Last reviewed November 15, 2026

See the timelineFirst payroll of 2027 checklist

Timeline

From enrollment to the first 2027 paycheck

Fit these steps to your own enrollment window and payroll calendar. The dated tasks for the whole payroll year-end are on the first payroll of 2027 checklist.

8 steps from open enrollment to a clean first quarter
WhenWhat happensLead teamDone when
Before open enrollment opensBenefits builds 2027 plans, options, rates and eligibility rules. Payroll creates or updates deduction codes and their tax setup.BenefitsEvery plan option maps to one payroll deduction code.
During open enrollmentHRIS sends test elections to a payroll test file. Payroll checks per-pay-period amounts for a sample.HRISA test file loads with no rejects.
Enrollment closesBenefits approves late changes and holds amounts that wait for evidence of insurability. HRIS freezes the election data.BenefitsOne final election file, with a record count.
Before the last 2026 payroll cutoffHRIS sends the 2027 election file with effective dates. Payroll loads it and end-dates 2026 deductions that stop.HRISThe deduction audit report matches the election file.
Preview of the first 2027 payrollPayroll runs a preview or parallel payroll with 2027 settings and reviews every difference.PayrollEvery difference has a reason.
First 2027 check dateNew deductions start. Employees check their pay stubs.PayrollEmployee questions are logged and answered.
First carrier and administrator invoicesBenefits and payroll tie deductions to invoices and to FSA and HSA files.BenefitsEvery difference is fixed or explained.
End of the first quarterCollect arrears, finish late life events and confirm year-to-date limits.PayrollNo open deduction issues.

The data handoff

What the election file must carry

Whether elections reach payroll by file, API or a manual load, each record needs these fields. Compare methods in the HRIS and payroll integration guide.

9 fields every 2027 election record needs
FieldFictional exampleWhy payroll needs it
Employee IDE1001The key that matches HRIS, benefits and payroll records. Never match on name.
Plan and optionMedical PPO, employee plus spouseTells payroll which deduction code to use.
Coverage level and who is coveredEmployee plus domestic partnerDrives the amount, and imputed income for a partner who is not a tax dependent.
Effective date and end datePlan year start, or the life event datePayroll turns it into the first and last affected check dates.
Employee amount per pay period$212.40What payroll deducts each check. Agree who rounds, and how.
Annual electionHealth FSA $3,500For FSAs and HSAs. Payroll uses it to spread the amount and check the limit.
Employer amountEmployer HSA $1,200 a yearCounts toward the HSA limit and goes on the Form W-2.
Tax treatmentPre-tax under section 125Set once on the deduction code, never person by person.
Change reason and dateOpen enrollment, new hire or life eventTells payroll whether to adjust past checks.

File feeds and effective dates

Preview what one change does to pay with the employee change impact checker. Roles and data owners are on the HRIS Desk.

Tax setup

Pre-tax or post-tax: set it on the deduction code

A section 125 cafeteria plan lets employees choose qualified benefits, such as health coverage, dependent care assistance, group-term life and HSAs, instead of cash. Choosing the benefit does not make it taxable. In most cases, excluded benefits are not subject to federal income tax withholding, Social Security, Medicare or FUTA (Pub. 15-B).

Federal treatment of common 2027 benefit deductions
DeductionFederal income taxSocial Security and MedicareNotesSource
Medical, dental and vision premiums through a section 125 planPre-taxPre-taxThe health exclusion covers employees, spouses, dependents and children under age 27. FUTA does not apply either.Pub. 15-B
Health FSAPre-taxPre-tax$3,500 limit in 2027. The plan may allow up to $700 carryover.Rev. Proc. 2026-35
Dependent care FSAPre-tax up to $7,500Pre-tax up to $7,500$3,750 for married filing separately. Amounts over the limit are wages.26 U.S.C. 129, Pub. 15-B
HSA through a section 125 planPre-tax up to the limitPre-taxTreated as employer contributions. Employee and employer amounts share one limit.Pub. 969
Traditional 401(k) deferralsPre-taxTaxedPre-tax elective deferrals are still subject to Social Security and Medicare.IRS
Roth 401(k) deferralsTaxedTaxedAfter-tax. Some catch-ups must be Roth.IRS, IRS catch-ups
Group-term life coverage over $50,000Withholding optionalTaxedThe cost of coverage over $50,000 is imputed income.Pub. 15-B
Coverage for a partner who is not a tax dependentTaxedTaxedThe value of the partner's coverage is generally imputed income.Pub. 15-B, IRS

State rules can differ, so check each state where you withhold. Section 125 elections are generally fixed for the plan year. A plan may allow mid-year changes only for permitted events, such as a change in marital status or number of dependents (26 CFR 1.125-4). For benefit-by-benefit treatment and imputed income, use the Benefit Guide.

Per-pay-period amounts

FSA and HSA math: spread the annual election

Divide the annual election by the pay dates left in the plan year. Round down to the cent and put the remainder in the last deduction, so the total matches the election exactly.

A health FSA must make the full annual election available at any time during the coverage period. That holds even before it is all deducted (Pub. 969).

Two fictional employees, paid biweekly

Sam Okafor (fictional) elects a $3,500 health FSA and a $7,500 dependent care FSA. Lee Varga (fictional) is 57, has family HDHP coverage and elects an HSA. Both work for Riverside Supply Co. (fictional), with 26 pay dates in 2027.

Made-up employees and employer. Not real people or a real company.
ElectionAnnual amountPay datesEach pay dateLast pay dateTotal
Health FSA (Sam), 26 pay dates$3,500.0026$134.61$134.75$3,500.00
Health FSA (Sam), if 2027 has 27 pay dates$3,500.0027$129.62$129.88$3,500.00
Dependent care FSA (Sam)$7,500.0026$288.46$288.50$7,500.00
HSA, employee share (Lee)$8,800.0026$338.46$338.50$8,800.00
HSA, employer share (Lee)$1,200.0026$46.15$46.25$1,200.00

Lee's HSA limit

HSA contributions need HDHP coverage. For 2027, an HDHP deductible is at least $1,750 self-only or $3,500 family. Out-of-pocket costs can be no more than $8,700 self-only or $17,400 family (Rev. Proc. 2026-24).

Paying on Fridays? 2027 can have 27 biweekly or 53 weekly pay dates. See 2027 has 53 Fridays. All 2027 limits are on the 2027 rates and limits page.

Testing

Test before the first 2027 payroll

  1. Load in a test environment first

    Load the full election file into a sandbox or preview. Count records in and out, and read every reject.

  2. Run a deduction audit report

    For every employee, compare the election file with payroll: deduction code, amount, start date, end date and tax treatment. Expect zero differences, or a written reason for each.

  3. Test the edge cases

    Run each case in the list below through the test load and the preview payroll.

  4. Run a preview payroll

    Compare net pay with the last 2026 check for a sample. Each change should trace to an election, a tax change or a limit.

  5. Sign off

    Benefits, HRIS and payroll each sign off before the live payroll runs.

Edge cases to test

A sample deduction audit report

Three fictional rows: one match and two differences to fix before payday
EmployeeDeductionElection per payPayroll per payDifferenceAction
E1001Medical PPO, employee plus spouse$212.40$212.40$0.00None.
E1002Health FSA$134.61$0.00$134.61FSA code not mapped. Fix the mapping, then reload.
E1003Dental, family$38.20$41.10$2.90Still on the 2026 rate. End-date the 2026 deduction.

Testing types and a go-live checklist are in the integration guide.

Reconciliation

Tie deductions to invoices and files

A deduction that ran is not proof that coverage, the carrier and the employee agree. Run these checks and give every difference an owner.

6 benefit deduction reconciliation checks
CheckCompareHow often
Elections to deductionsElection file amounts against the payroll deduction registerEvery payroll in January, then monthly
Carrier invoicesPeople and coverage levels on each invoice against people with that deductionEach invoice
Premium totalsEmployee share collected plus employer share against the invoice totalMonthly
Health and dependent care FSAPayroll deductions against what your FSA administrator receivedEvery payroll
HSAEmployee and employer amounts against the custodian funding file, and year-to-date against the limitEvery payroll
Imputed incomeImputed income earnings against people with partner coverage or group-term life over $50,000Monthly and at year-end

A fictional January 2027 medical invoice review

Northgate Health Plan (fictional) invoice against payroll deductions. Made-up records.
EmployeeOn the invoiceDeduction in payrollAction
E1004Yes, employee onlyNoneMissed deduction. Start it, and collect the gap under your written arrears rules.
E1005NoYes, familyDeducting with no coverage. Enroll if the election was valid, or stop and refund.
E1006Yes, employee plus childrenYes, employee onlyCoverage level mismatch. Check the election and fix the source record.
E1007YesNone, terminated in December 2026Ask the carrier to end coverage on the right date and credit the invoice.

Common errors

Common errors and how to fix them

Fix the cause at the source, then fix the paycheck. Add each one to next year's test cases.

12 open enrollment to payroll errors
SymptomLikely causeHow to fix it
Deduction missing on the first 2027 checkThe election file arrived after the cutoff, or the plan code is not mapped.Map the code and reload. Collect the missed amount under your written arrears rules, and tell the employee before payday.
Employee still paying the 2026 amountThe 2026 deduction was not end-dated, so two rows overlap.End-date each 2026 deduction at the end of the 2026 plan year. Rerun the audit report.
Wrong FSA amount per checkThe annual election was divided by the wrong number of pay dates.Count real 2027 pay dates, including any 27th biweekly or 53rd weekly date. Recalculate the remaining checks.
HSA contributions over the limitEmployer money was not counted, or someone under 55 got the catch-up.Count employee and employer amounts together against one limit. Stop at the limit and correct with the custodian.
Life event change missingA marriage, birth or adoption was approved in the benefits system but never reached payroll.Send the change with its event date and adjust deductions from the right check. DOL says to request enrollment within 30 days of these events.
Deductions not taken during a leaveUnpaid leave, or pay too low to cover the deduction.Track arrears by plan. Agree in writing how much to collect per check, and whether pre-tax or post-tax.
Catch-up contributions not startingThe age 50 or ages 60 to 63 rule was not set for 2027 birthdays, or the Roth catch-up wage test is missing.Load birth dates and 2026 wages from the plan sponsor. Final Roth catch-up regulations generally apply from 2027 (90 FR 44527).
No imputed income for partner coverageThe election shows a coverage level, but not who is covered or their tax dependent status.Capture the covered person's relationship and dependent status. Set up an imputed income earning code.
Employee missed enrollmentNo election by the deadline, so the plan's default applied.Follow the plan document. Allow changes after the deadline only for events the plan permits, and record the decision.
Terminated employee still on the invoiceThe termination reached payroll but not the carrier file.Send the termination to the carrier, fix the feed and check the invoice credit.
Monthly premium taken every biweekly checkA monthly rate was loaded where a per-pay-period rate was expected.Agree the rate basis in the file specification. Convert once, in one place.
Group-term life imputed income missingCoverage over $50,000 was never sent to payroll.Include the cost of coverage over $50,000 in wages. It is subject to Social Security and Medicare (Pub. 15-B).

Who does what: benefits, HRIS and payroll

A starting point to adjust for your organization. Each row has one accountable team.

R
Responsible: does the work
A
Accountable: owns the outcome and signs off
C
Consulted: gives input before
I
Informed: told after
RACI for 15 open enrollment to payroll activities
ActivityBenefitsHRISPayroll
Plan design, rates and eligibility rulesA/RCI
Deduction codes and tax treatment in payrollCIA/R
Open enrollment setup and employee communicationA/RRI
Election data qualityARI
Election file build, schedule and monitoringCA/RI
Loading elections into payrollICA/R
Per-pay-period amounts and rounding rulesCCA/R
Deduction audit report before the first 2027 payrollCRA/R
Preview or parallel payrollCCA/R
Carrier and administrator invoice reconciliationA/RIR
Life events and mid-year changesA/RRI
Arrears rulesAIR
Imputed income values and setupRCA
Catch-up eligibility and the Roth catch-up wage testACR
Employee questions about the first 2027 paycheckRIA/R

A/R means the same team is accountable and does the work. The wider HR, payroll, IT and Finance RACI is in the integration guide.

For employees

Check your first 2027 paycheck

Share this section with employees. It takes five minutes with your pay stub and your benefits confirmation.

A note you can adapt and send

Your first 2027 paycheck includes your new benefit elections. Please compare each deduction with your benefits confirmation. If you earned more than $184,500 in 2026, Social Security tax starts again this year. If anything looks wrong, contact payroll within one week and include your employee ID.

Help reading a pay stub: how to read your pay stub and your paycheck, explained. Sources: SSA, IRS and Form W-4.

Open enrollment to payroll questions

What effective date should payroll use for 2027 elections?

Use the plan year start, or the life event date for mid-year changes. Then agree whether deductions follow the coverage period or the check date. Write the rule down and test it. See the timeline.

What is the 2027 health FSA limit?

It is $3,500 in salary reductions. If the plan allows carryover, the maximum carryover is $700. See Rev. Proc. 2026-35.

Do employer HSA contributions count toward the limit?

Yes. Employee and employer contributions share one limit: $4,500 self-only or $9,000 family in 2027. Contributions through a cafeteria plan count as employer contributions. See Publication 969 and Rev. Proc. 2026-24.

Is the 2027 dependent care FSA limit $7,500?

Yes. Public Law 119-21 raised it from $5,000 to $7,500, or $3,750 for married filing separately, starting in 2026. It is not indexed, so $7,500 applies in 2027. See 26 U.S.C. 129.

Can employees change elections mid-year?

Only for events the plan allows under the cafeteria plan rules, such as marriage, divorce, birth or a change in employment status. The change must be consistent with the event. See 26 CFR 1.125-4 and DOL special enrollment.

Why does domestic partner coverage create imputed income?

The federal health exclusion covers employees, spouses, dependents and children under 27. A registered domestic partner is not a spouse for federal tax purposes. Unless the partner qualifies as a dependent, the coverage value is generally taxable. See the Benefit Guide.

What happens if an employee missed open enrollment?

The plan document sets the default, such as keeping current coverage or no coverage. Do not add elections after the deadline unless the plan allows it for a qualifying event. Common errors.

What changes for catch-up contributions in 2027?

Final IRS regulations on Roth catch-ups generally apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2026. For 2027, employees whose 2026 Form W-2 Box 3 wages from the plan sponsor exceed $155,000 generally must make catch-ups as Roth. See IRS Notice 2026-66.

More for benefits and payroll teams

Official sources

Each figure, date and rule on this page was checked on these official pages on November 9, 2026.

General information, not tax or legal advice. Your plan documents, carriers and advisors decide how these rules apply to your plans.