Pay rules · equity and offers
Equity awards and offer letters
An offer with equity is harder to compare than one with a bigger salary. This page explains how each type of equity award is taxed, what happens at vesting and when you leave, and how payroll reports it. Then it walks through an offer letter and compares two offers side by side.
RSUs, options and ESPPs
Types of equity awards and when they are taxed
How equity is taxed depends on the type of award. With stock options, you may have income at any of three points (IRS Topic 427). They are when you receive the option, when you exercise it, and when you sell the option or the stock.
| Award | When it is taxed | Forms and reporting |
|---|---|---|
| Restricted stock | When it becomes substantially vested: its fair market value minus what you paid. It is substantially vested when it is transferable or no longer at substantial risk of forfeiture (Pub 525). | Unless you file an 83(b) election. |
| Restricted stock units (RSUs) | Not fully confirmed. RSUs are generally taxed as wages when the shares are delivered, usually at vesting. They are often withheld at the 22 percent supplemental rate (IRS Publication 15). The research found no IRS page that says this directly. Publication 525 confirms only that RSUs are settled in stock. | Check your plan and your pay statement at each vesting date. |
| Nonstatutory stock options (NSOs) | No tax at grant if the option has no readily determinable value. At exercise, you include the stock's fair market value minus what you paid (Topic 427). | The employer reports the spread at exercise on Form W-2 as wages, in boxes 1, 3 and 5 (Pub 15-B). |
| Incentive stock options (ISOs) | Generally no regular tax when you receive or exercise the option. You may owe alternative minimum tax (AMT) in the year you exercise (Topic 427). | Form 3921 for each transfer of stock when you exercise (Form 3921 instructions). |
| Employee stock purchase plan (ESPP, section 423) | The purchase price can be as low as 85 percent of the stock's fair market value: up to a 15 percent discount (Pub 525). | Form 3922 for the first transfer of legal title of shares bought at less than 100 percent of the grant-date value (instructions). |
ISOs and ESPP shares: the holding period
To get capital gain treatment on ISO or ESPP shares, you must hold them long enough (Pub 525). Keep them until the later of 2 years after the grant and 1 year after the shares were transferred to you.
- March 1, 2026: grantRiley (fictional) receives ISOs.
- September 1, 2026: exerciseRiley exercises, and the shares are transferred.
- September 1, 20271 year after transfer.
- March 1, 20282 years after grant. This is the later date, so Riley holds until then.
Sell ISO shares before the holding period ends, and the gain is ordinary income up to the spread at exercise. Federal income tax withholding is not required on that income. ISO exercise income is also not Social Security or Medicare wages (Pub 525, Pub 15-B).
Employment requirement. For statutory options, you must be an employee of the granting company or a related company from grant until 3 months before you exercise. For a disabled ISO holder, it is 1 year (Pub 525).
P.A.Y. practice
- Before exercising ISOs, estimate AMT for the year with a tax professional.
- Keep every Form 3921, Form 3922 and brokerage statement. Brokers often report a cost basis that leaves out income already on your W-2, which can cause double tax if you do not adjust.
30 days
The 83(b) election
An 83(b) election lets you include restricted property in income in the year it is transferred, instead of when it vests. You must file it no later than 30 days after the property was transferred (Pub 525).
After the election, later growth in value is not included in your pay when the property vests. The risk: if the property is forfeited after an 83(b) election, your loss is limited to the amount you paid for it.
Fictional example
Casey receives 10,000 restricted shares on June 1, 2026, worth $0.50 each, and pays nothing. With an 83(b) election filed by July 1, 2026, Casey includes $5,000 in income for 2026. If the shares are worth $4.00 each when they vest, the $35,000 of growth is not taxed as pay. If Casey forfeits the shares instead, the loss is limited to the $0 paid.
P.A.Y. practice
- If you get restricted stock and think an 83(b) election makes sense, calendar the 30-day deadline the day you receive the shares.
When you own it
Vesting schedules and cliffs
The vesting schedule, any cliff, and what happens at termination are set by the plan and your grant agreement, not by tax law. Read both.
A common pattern is a 1-year cliff, then monthly or quarterly vesting. Plans vary widely, so check yours.
| When | Shares vested | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Before month 12 | 0 | Nothing has vested. Leaving now usually forfeits it all. |
| Month 12 (the cliff) | 1,000 | 25 percent vests at once. |
| Each quarter after that | 250 more | 12 more vesting dates. |
| Month 24 | 2,000 | Half vested. |
| Month 36 | 3,000 | Three quarters vested. |
| Month 48 | 4,000 | Fully vested. |
Plan-dependent
What usually happens to equity when you leave
It depends on your plan. These are common patterns, not rules:
- Unvested awards are often forfeited.
- Vested options often must be exercised within a set window after you leave.
- ISOs lose ISO tax treatment if exercised more than 3 months after employment ends, except for disability (Pub 525). Check the plan's exercise window as well.
Planning a departure? The separation guide covers final pay, severance and benefits.
Withholding and the W-2
How payroll handles equity income
- NSO exercise. The spread is wages on Form W-2, in boxes 1, 3 and 5 (Pub 15-B). Payroll runs it like other wages.
- ISO sold early. The ordinary income from a disqualifying disposition needs no federal income tax withholding. ISO exercise income is not Social Security or Medicare wages (Pub 15-B).
- ISO exercise and ESPP purchase. The company files Form 3921 or Form 3922 and gives you a copy (instructions).
Not fully confirmed. RSUs are generally taxed as wages when the shares are delivered, usually at vesting. They are often withheld at the 22 percent supplemental rate (IRS Publication 15). The research found no IRS page that says this directly. Publication 525 confirms only that RSUs are settled in stock.
To see what flat-rate withholding does to a lump sum, try the bonus and gross-up calculator. For the 2027 Social Security wage base and other limits, see 2027 payroll tax rates.
P.A.Y. practice
- Set aside cash for taxes when RSUs vest. Withholding at a flat supplemental rate may be too low for higher earners.
- Payroll and HRIS teams: get vesting and exercise data from the equity administrator before each payroll cutoff. See the HRIS guide.
Read before you sign
Offer letter reading checklist
An offer letter sets pay, status and benefits expectations before you start. Read it for these 13 items, and get any promise that matters to you in writing.
- Base pay. Confirm the amount, pay frequency and first pay date.
- FLSA status. Confirm whether the job is exempt or nonexempt from overtime. If nonexempt, confirm how overtime is paid.
- Bonus. Is it discretionary or formula-based? Confirm the target, how it is measured, and whether you must be employed on the payout date.
- Equity. Confirm the type (RSU, NSO, ISO), the number of shares or target value, and the grant date or approval timing. Confirm the vesting schedule and cliff, and what happens if you leave or the company is sold.
- Start date. Confirm it, and any conditions that could delay it.
- At-will language. Most offers say either side can end employment at any time. A written promise of a fixed term is different.
- Contingencies. Look for a background check, drug test, references, and the Form I-9 work authorization check. Ask what happens if a check is delayed.
- Benefits start. When does health coverage start: day one, or the first of the month after a waiting period? When do 401(k) matching and vesting start? See the retirement guide.
- PTO. Confirm the amount, how it accrues, whether it carries over, and whether unused PTO is paid out at separation. See the PTO payout calculator.
- Sign-on bonus. Read any clawback clause. Note how long you must stay, and whether repayment is full or prorated, and gross or net of taxes.
- Relocation. Read any repayment clause. Note what is reimbursed, what is grossed up for taxes, and when repayment ends. Most moving payments are taxable; see reimbursement types.
- Non-compete and non-solicit. Read the scope, length and geography. Rules vary by state, and federal rules have changed several times since 2023, so check current law where you live.
- Verbal promises. Ask for any verbal promise, such as a remote work arrangement or a title, to be added to the letter before you sign.
Non-compete rules keep changing
On February 14, 2025, the NLRB Acting General Counsel issued memo GC 25-05. It rescinded the earlier General Counsel memos on non-compete agreements, GC 23-08 and GC 25-01 (NLRB).
Not fully confirmed. The status of the Federal Trade Commission's Non-Compete Clause Rule as of November 2026 could not be confirmed on an official source. Check current federal and state law before you rely on any non-compete rule.
Offer comparison worksheet
Compare two offers: first year and four years
Enter each offer's base pay, target bonus, sign-on bonus, equity and 401(k) match formula. The worksheet adds them up for the first year and for four years. Equity is valued at a share price you assume; it is not a forecast.
Four-year difference
$0.00
Enter at least the base pay for both offers to compare them.
How it was figured
Download this result:
The method
How the comparison is figured, with a worked example
| Part | Formula |
|---|---|
| Base pay | Base × 1 for the first year, × 4 for four years. No raises. |
| Target bonus | Base × the target percent, every year. |
| Sign-on bonus | Counted once, in the first year. A clawback clause can take it back if you leave early. |
| Equity | Shares × (assumed price − exercise price, never below 0). Spread evenly over the vesting years: the first year gets 1 ÷ years, four years get up to all of it. |
| 401(k) match | Base × the matched share of pay. Tier 1 matches your contribution up to its limit at its rate; tier 2 matches the next part at its rate. |
Worked example (fictional offers)
- Offer A: $120,000 base and a 10% target bonus. A $10,000 sign-on bonus. 400 RSUs at an assumed $50 a share, over 4 years. A match of 100% of the first 4% of pay.
- Offer B: $110,000 base and a 15% target bonus. No sign-on bonus. 2,000 options with a $10 exercise price, at an assumed $30 a share, over 4 years. A match of 100% of the first 3% plus 50% of the next 2%.
You contribute 6% at either job.
| Item | A, first year | A, four years | B, first year | B, four years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base pay | $120,000.00 | $480,000.00 | $110,000.00 | $440,000.00 |
| Target bonus (10% and 15%) | $12,000.00 | $48,000.00 | $16,500.00 | $66,000.00 |
| Sign-on bonus | $10,000.00 | $10,000.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Equity at the assumed price | $5,000.00 | $20,000.00 | $10,000.00 | $40,000.00 |
| 401(k) match at a 6% contribution | $4,800.00 | $19,200.00 | $4,400.00 | $17,600.00 |
| Total | $151,800.00 | $577,200.00 | $140,900.00 | $563,600.00 |
Offer A comes out $10,900.00 ahead in the first year and $13,600.00 ahead over four years. Change the assumed prices and the answer can flip, which is why the worksheet labels them as assumptions. Load this example in the worksheet.
Frequently asked questions
What is the deadline for an 83(b) election?
You must file it no later than 30 days after the restricted property is transferred to you. Calendar the deadline the day you receive the shares. See the 83(b) election.
Do I owe tax when I exercise ISOs?
Generally not for regular tax. You may owe alternative minimum tax in the year you exercise. Estimate it with a tax professional first. See ISOs.
How long must I hold ISO or ESPP shares?
Until the later of 2 years after the grant and 1 year after the shares were transferred to you. Selling sooner turns part of the gain into ordinary income. See the holding period.
What happens to my equity if I leave?
It depends on your plan. Unvested awards are often forfeited, and vested options often have a set exercise window. See equity when you leave.
Why is my stock option income on my W-2?
For nonstatutory options, the spread at exercise is wages. Employers report it in W-2 boxes 1, 3 and 5. See how payroll handles equity.
What are Forms 3921 and 3922?
Form 3921 reports stock transferred when you exercise an ISO. Form 3922 reports the first transfer of ESPP shares bought below the grant-date value. Keep both for your tax return. See award types.
Is the non-compete in my offer letter enforceable?
It depends on state law and on the clause's scope, length and geography. Federal rules have changed several times since 2023. See the offer letter checklist.
How does the offer comparison value equity?
It uses a share price you assume, which is not a forecast. The value is spread evenly over the vesting years. Downloads need a free P.A.Y. profile. See the worksheet.
Is anything I enter in the worksheet saved?
No. The worksheet runs on your device, and nothing you type is stored or sent. Closing the page clears it. Back to the worksheet.
Related guides and tools
- 401(k) calculatorContributions, the match and the IRS limits.
- Retirement guideHow 401(k) plans, vesting and rollovers work.
- Bonus and gross-up calculatorFlat-rate withholding on a bonus or sign-on payment.
- Separation guideFinal pay, severance, COBRA and unemployment.
- 2027 payroll tax rates and limitsThe 2027 wage base and other limits.
- Corporate-owned life insuranceCOLI, group-term life and imputed income.
Official sources
Each figure, date and rule on this page was checked on these official pages on November 9, 2026.
- IRS Publication 15 (2026), Employer's Tax Guide, What's New
- IRS Topic no. 427: stock options
- IRS Publication 15-B (2026), Employer's Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits (including Table 2-2)
- IRS Publication 525 (2025), Taxable and Nontaxable Income
- IRS Instructions for Forms 3921 and 3922 (04/2025)
- NLRB: GC 25-05, rescission of certain General Counsel memoranda